Freshly Made Pies, Cakes

and Tasty Treats

Online ordering is temporarily suspended until April 5th

Due to the increased demand surrounding the Easter holiday, the deadline for orders to be picked up during the holiday week was Wednesday 3/31 by the end of the day to ensure fulfillment. 

In the process of filling orders, extra pies may possibly be made and can be purchased at the front of restaurant on a first-come first-serve basis.


If you have a Pie Coupon and did not meet the order deadline, you can still redeem your coupon with the available selection in the pie case or anytime after the holiday. Leiby's Pie Coupons will NOT EXPIRE and can be used ANYTIME you make a purchase.